He Buys Me Gifts. I Want to Save. How Do We Make This Work?
Receiving Gifts Love Language and Budget Conflict in Marriage
This love language—and the potential for conflict—is the one that hits closest to home for me.
My husband’s primary love language is Receiving Gifts (and giving them!), and mine is decidedly ….not. I’m a numbers-oriented, goal-seeking, quality-time type of girl.
So when we set a financial goal and I have a purpose for every dollar, I tend to get ascetic and often I’m too strict with the budget.
But what happens when the person you love feels loved when you think of them, pick out a meaningful gift, and surprise them with it—even if it’s small? For them, love is tangible. And that can easily clash with a saver’s mindset.
What the Receiving Gifts Love Language Really Means
For those who speak the Receiving Gifts love language, it’s not about accumulating stuff. It’s about being thought of and being acknowledge as important.
Many of my extended family members show their love by picking up a small item that matches someone’s interest or decor. That butter dish or plant isn’t about the object. It’s about the care behind it.
If you don’t speak this love language, you might misinterpret it as materialism. But to someone who values gifts, a well-chosen present says:
“I know you.”
“I was thinking of you.”
“I cherish you.”
One of my husband’s favorite gifts I’ve given is a glass set etched with the map of every city we’ve lived in. Every time he uses one, it reminds him of our shared history. Do we have too many glasses now? Maybe. But it is up to me to get rid of those extra glasses or cups that I keep “just in case” - but don’t have the same importance as his favorite glasses.
Where Financial Conflict Shows Up
This is an easy spot for marital tension:
One spouse feels loved when money is spent on meaningful gifts.
The other feels stress—or even fear—about spending.
To the person giving or receiving gifts, stopping that flow can feel like being forgotten. Even a thoughtless gift—something perfunctory or last-minute—can hurt.
And conflict doesn’t just come from receiving. When a gift-loving spouse gives you something as an act of love, it can feel like pressure if that’s not your language. Suddenly, you’re keeping score. You feel like you have to reciprocate in a way that might not come naturally—or might not be in the budget.
When Financial Trauma Meets the Gifts Love Language
It gets even more complex when financial trauma or a scarcity mindset enters the picture.
Let’s say one spouse grew up around overspending, instability, or even foreclosure. For them, spending might feel like a threat. Their instinct is to control every penny.
The trouble is—love isn’t logical. You can’t convince someone to feel loved in a way that doesn’t resonate. Your rational, budget-friendly actions might make sense to you, but they don’t land emotionally if your spouse experiences love through gifts.
One of the most common things I see is a spouse saying, “But this way makes more sense!” Maybe it does. But if it doesn’t connect emotionally—it’s not love to the other person.
Navigating Gifts in a Budget-Conscious Marriage
Here’s what’s helped us:
1. Set Boundaries Together
Create a monthly “gifts” line item in the budget. Set a dollar limit—then honor it.
2. Give Each Other Freedom
Decide: “This is your gift budget. Use it in a way that brings you joy.” No guilt, no micromanaging.
3. Shift the Focus to Meaning
A $5 thrift-store treasure that shows thought can carry more weight than a $50 gadget.
Example:
For Valentine’s Day, we didn’t have money set aside, but my husband found a hardbound copy of A Tree Grows in Brooklyn—my favorite childhood book. Thoughtful. Beautiful. Secondhand. Perfect.
For the Spouse Who Doesn’t Value Gifts
If you’re not a gift person, don’t dismiss this love language.
It’s easy to see a gift-lover as materialistic or greedy—but that’s contempt. It’s one of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse that John Gottman speaks about in The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work. Cultivating an attitude of contempt predicts divorce. It poisons love.
You don’t need to suddenly become a gifter. But you do need to become a student of your spouse.
Ask Questions to Learn What Matters to Them:
“What’s a gift you still think about?”
“What hobbies do you wish you could do more?”
“What’s something you wish you had that you wouldn’t buy for yourself?”
Take notes. Save ideas. Put reminders in your phone.
Because when we speak love in a language our spouse understands—even if it’s not our own—we build trust, connection, and emotional warmth.
TL;DR: Gifts, Love, and the Budget
When one spouse sees giving or receiving gifts as a sign of love—and the other sees spending as stressful—it can feel like you're speaking different emotional languages. Understanding what’s really being communicated through gifts can reduce tension and help you find common ground. With empathy, boundaries, and intentionality, your marriage can honor both your budget and your love.
This post contains affiliate links. That means if you purchase something through these links, I may earn a small commission—at no cost to you. I only recommend things I use, respect, or love.