Ghosts of Budgets Past: Letting Go of Old Money Stories After a Breakup
TL;DR: What old money stories are shaping your spending?
After a breakup, it's common to keep budgeting based on past dynamics. This post helps you recognize unconscious habits and offers practical ways to create a budget that reflects who you are now. Includes practical steps and a free journaling guide.
What Is a Money Story—and Why It Matters After Divorce
Everyone's money story is deeply personal. It's the unique collection of beliefs, habits, and narratives we carry about money. And while there are common themes reflected in throughout society, each money story is unique to each person.
One money story I carry deep in my core stems from my formative years and the message I received from my family of origin: always strive for the best quality at the cheapest price, even if it means an inordinate amount of research. Add to that my own tendency to avoid making "a wrong decision," and sometimes I never make the decision at all. This often leads to regretting that I waited for "a better price" and subsequently paying more for the item I’m shopping for.
““Even when you divorce, these stories may have lodged themselves deep in your identity or how you see yourself.””
People who were deeply impacted by poverty as children often have a scarcity mindset, meaning they fundamentally believe money is insecure. This might mean that whenever there’s a little money, they should spend it right away—because they won’t have any in the future. They can also feel overwhelmed or indecisive, or they might feel as though they’ll never get ahead.
Other ways this can show up:
Believing that everyone is in debt, so you’ll always be in debt
Thinking you can’t afford nice things and always have to settle for cheaply made ones
Believing you’re "dumb with money" because your ex told you so
Whether we want to or not, we carry financial baggage from our relationships—whether family of origin or intimate.
The Invisible Budget: When Your Ex Is Still in Your Spreadsheet
A belief that many people hold is that once you divorce, you’ll get a fresh start. Unfortunately—especially if you have children—untangling yourself from your ex is a far longer and more difficult experience than people imagine when struggling in the marriage.
“Untangling yourself from your ex is a far longer and more difficult experience than people imagine.”
One frequent way people ‘keep their ex’ in the budget is by competing with them through spending, especially when kids are involved. If your ex takes them to a waterpark and for ice cream afterward, you might feel pressure to go big on a shopping spree at the mall when it’s your turn.
I've had many clients share the sense that if they seem to be doing well financially, their ex won’t feel obligated to support them or the kids. This can be especially tricky in situations where support payments aren’t court-ordered and rely on mutual agreement or a sense of fairness. In those cases, one parent may quietly depend on the other's sense of guilt or duty to help.
Another common tension? One parent adding expenses like competitive sports or music lessons to the shared budget—putting the other parent in a no-win situation if they disagree.
Voices in Your Head: Whose Financial Standards Are You Still Following?
There are a number of psychological and social reasons influencing your financial decisions, especially after a hard breakup or divorce.
If you’re emotionally raw, you might seek validation from friends and family or avoid conflict in other areas of life. This can result in subtle people-pleasing that threatens your financial stability. For example: feeling like you have to pick up the tab—even though your income has changed dramatically.
Parental Scripts That Stick
The unconscious beliefs we absorb in childhood can also stick around long after we’ve grown up. Some familiar examples:
“Money doesn’t grow on trees.”
“Let’s treat ourselves—we finally have a little money.”
“Always appear successful, no matter the cost.”
“Don’t talk about money.”
“Always get the cheapest deal.”
This kind of background can make you feel like there's one “right way” to do things—which often results in indecision or anxiety around money.
“You now have the ability and freedom to re-evaluate your financial goals.”
When you're navigating your finances independently, it's crucial to redefine what financial success means to you. Maybe your previous definition came from your ex’s need to keep up appearances. Now, success might look more like peace of mind.
Or perhaps you were married to someone extremely frugal—even tight-fisted. In that case, you're now free to find a more balanced approach. Either way, the goal is the same: progress toward financial health, on your terms.
This process is often part of a larger journey toward emotional and financial stability. To explore the full scope of this work, read our full guide on finding financial peace without a spouse
Budgeting from Self-Respect, Not Deprivation
We’ve talked about how post-divorce challenges can lead to overspending—but the opposite is just as common. Many recently divorced individuals swing hard toward restriction and deprivation.
And it's understandable. When money is tight, the fear of an uncertain future can create immense pressure.
“The true purpose of a budget is to provide knowledge and clarity.”
A real budget helps you make intentional choices. When you know what you’ve allocated and track your spending in real time, things feel clearer. Tools like YNAB or EveryDollar can help you feel more confident, and even proud, of how you’re handling your money.
That said, the temptation to compare will always be there—especially if you're grieving the life you thought you’d have. That grief can quickly turn to guilt or shame.
If you’re struggling in this way, please reach out. You don’t have to process this alone.
Small Ways to Start Rewriting Your Story
Dragging emotional and relational baggage behind you—without acknowledging or processing it—is like trying to run while carrying an anchor.
So how do you move forward?
Here are a few quick wins to help you start:
Rename your budget categories
Try something like "Self-Reliance" or "Peace of Mind" instead of generic names. It can shift your whole outlook.Journal before reviewing spending
Just a few moments of reflection before looking at your numbers can quiet judgment and bring clarity.Declutter your financial world
Cancel unused subscriptions. Close old accounts. Remove yourself from joint credit cards.
And Finally, ask yourself this question: “What would a thoughtful, realistic budget look like for me today?” This isn’t about bitterness or re-litigating old fights, or living up to what you thought your financial life would look like - or how your ex thought your financial life should look.
These small changes help you reclaim your financial narrative—on your own terms.
Releasing the Past, Embracing Your Future
Untangling yourself from the ghosts of financial choices past isn’t easy. But it is necessary.
Understanding your money story, recognizing lingering influence from past relationships, and redefining what financial success looks like now—that’s what opens the door to real peace and stability.
It’s time to write a new chapter. One that reflects your values and serves you.
Or download the free journaling guide below to reflect on what’s still shaping your spending—and take your first step toward clarity and confidence.
This post may contain affiliate links. That means if you purchase something through these links, I may earn a small commission—at no cost to you. I only recommend things I use, respect, or love.